I Broke a Few Brains on the Show. Let’s Settle the “Senior vs. Junior” Debate.

For many of you, I’m a trusted source of knowledge. So when I go on a tangent during the live show, you lean in, ready for something that challenges the way you think.

MITMCIGAR DROP IN

The show is live every Sunday, share this Substack. LINK

Now to the Point…

Well, last night I think I succeeded. I hit you with a classic “devil’s advocate” scenario that got the entire chat buzzing, and judging by the comments, I officially broke a few brains. The topic was simple, but the implications were surprisingly complex: family naming conventions.

LeeMack912 and Hyacinth ripped me one! Oh and Chat!

Watch the full MITMCIGAR Video

The “Jr. Promotion” Theory That Started It All

I laid out this bullshuck proposition for you all: Imagine a family with Antonio Sr. and his son, Antonio Jr. When Antonio Sr. passes away, does Antonio Jr. get a “field promotion” and inherit the title of Sr.?

It’s an appealing idea, isn’t it? It sounds like the natural order of things, a passing of the torch, a graduation. For a moment, I had you. I could see the gears turning as you wondered if everything you thought you knew about names was wrong. The theory is captivating because it adds a layer of drama and legacy to a name.

The Official Ruling: Seen

After letting you all scramble down that genealogical rabbit hole, I’m here to set the record straight. As fun as the “promotion” theory is, it’s not how it works. LeeMack912 was right!

Your name suffix is not a job title; it’s a permanent identifier.

Think of “Jr.” and “Sr.” as fixed points in your family’s history. They are assigned at birth to distinguish a child from a parent with the exact same name, and they stick around for life.

  • Antonio Sr. is, and always will be, the first to hold the name in this line. That’s his legacy, and the title is forever his.

  • Antonio Jr. was named in honor of his father. He carries the “Jr.” suffix for his entire life as a badge of that direct connection.

  • If Antonio Jr. has a son and also names him Antonio, that child becomes Antonio III, continuing the direct, unbroken line.

Break the Chain: When the Count Resets?

This is where the hypothetical got even crazier. I asked you what would happen if Antonio III has a firstborn son but names him Miguel, breaking the chain of Antonios. If he then has a second son and names him Antonio, is that baby Antonio IV?

The answer is a definitive no.

Because Miguel, the glorious chain-breaker, interrupted the sacred line, the count resets. The new baby Antonio would simply be his father’s junior. There is no Antonio IV because there was no direct line from III to IV.

So there you have it. My goal on the show is always to take things we take for granted, turn them on their heads, and get us all thinking. It was a fun rabbit hole to explore with all of you.

Just have to say, I learn a ton from this community. Shout out to you, LeeMack912, and Hyacinth! You’ve really inspired me on my journey to become a more intelligent, curious person. I wouldn’t be who I am without you.

Thanks for playing along. Stay hype, stay curious.